You've just experienced a fender bender or discovered a cracked windshield. Your first instinct might be to file an insurance claim—after all, isn't that why you pay those premiums? But before you make that call, it's worth considering a crucial question: Should you file a claim or just pay for the repairs yourself?
What the big insurance companies don't tell you is that filing a claim isn't always in your best financial interest. In fact, even minor claims can lead to years of premium increases that far exceed the original repair costs.
Let's break down when you should use your insurance and when it makes more sense to reach for your wallet instead—information that could save you thousands in the long run.
Insurance companies market themselves as your financial protector, ready to help when accidents happen. What they don't advertise is how quickly they'll raise your rates after you use their services—even for small claims.
Here's what a single claim can do to your premiums:
These increases vary by state and insurer, but the pattern is clear: claims lead to higher premiums, often for years. That $800 fender repair could end up costing you $2,100 in premium increases over three years—more than 2.5 times the original repair cost!
Not all accidents warrant an insurance claim. Use this simple formula to determine if filing is worth it:
If (Repair Cost - Deductible) < (Potential Premium Increase × 3 years), pay out of pocket.
For example:
This formula isn't exact (your actual premium increase might vary), but it provides a helpful guideline when deciding whether to file a claim.
If repairs will cost $800 and your deductible is $500, you'll only get $300 from insurance—likely not worth the potential premium increase. This is especially true if you have previous claims on your record.
Multiple claims in a short period (usually 3 years) can trigger dramatic rate increases or even non-renewal. If you've already filed a claim in the past three years, consider paying out of pocket for minor incidents.
Small dents, chipped paint, cracked windshields, or minor cosmetic damage often falls below deductibles anyway. Even when they don't, the long-term cost of filing usually exceeds the immediate repair cost.
Backing into a pole, scraping a garage door, or similar minor incidents where you're at fault and no one else is involved are usually better handled without insurance involvement.
If you're in a minor accident and the at-fault driver offers to pay for your repairs directly, this can often be faster and financially better for both parties (though make sure to document everything).
Not all situations warrant paying out of pocket. You should definitely file a claim when:
When repair costs significantly exceed your deductible (generally by $1,000+), filing a claim usually makes financial sense.
Never handle accidents with injuries privately. Medical costs can escalate quickly, and proper documentation through insurance is essential.
When you've damaged someone else's property or caused injury, letting your insurance handle it protects you from potential legal complications and unexpected costs.
If you can't easily determine how extensive the damage is (like potential frame damage), file a claim to ensure proper assessment and repairs.
Comprehensive claims for theft, weather damage, or animal collisions typically don't impact your premiums as significantly as collision claims.
At OCHO, we understand the dilemma drivers face when deciding whether to file a claim. While traditional insurers often punish customers for using their insurance, we take a different approach:
Traditional insurers have perfected a profitable cycle:
Think about this business model: You pay for a service that you're financially incentivized NOT to use. It's like paying for an all-you-can-eat buffet where each plate of food increases the entry fee for the next three years!
Beyond deciding when to pay out of pocket, these strategies can help protect your claims history:
Insurance is a financial tool, and like any tool, it should be used strategically. Sometimes filing a claim is the right move; other times, paying out of pocket saves you money in the long run. The key is making this decision with complete information about the potential consequences.
OCHO believes car insurance should be transparent and fair. Our revolutionary approach ensures you understand your options and can make decisions that truly benefit your financial future—not just the insurance company's bottom line.
No one looks after you like OCHO does.
Ready to experience the OCHO difference? Get a quote today and discover how our approach to insurance makes quality coverage accessible without the typical industry games.
Will my insurance company find out about an accident if I don't file a claim?
Possibly. If police were called, there's an accident report, or the other party files a claim with their insurer, your company may learn about the incident. However, many minor incidents remain unknown to insurers if not reported.
Does getting an estimate from my insurance company count as a claim?
Generally no. Most insurers allow you to get an estimate without it counting as a filed claim. However, the incident may still be noted on your record as an "inquiry" even if you don't proceed.
How long do claims affect my insurance rates?
Typically 3-5 years, depending on your state and insurer. After this period, the claim usually "falls off" your insurance history.
Will my rates increase even if the accident wasn't my fault?
In many states, yes—though the increase is typically smaller than for at-fault accidents. Some states have laws preventing increases for not-at-fault accidents, and some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs.
Can my insurance company cancel my policy for filing too many claims?
Yes. While regulations vary by state, most insurers can choose not to renew your policy if you file multiple claims within a short period (typically 3 years), especially if they're at-fault accidents.
.svg)
